charles
FRAUD
Expose Truth.Fight Injustice.Demand Action.

THE WHISTLEBLOWER FILES

Summarizing the Scheme
with the Proven Facts
I recommend first reading the Summary below, and then continuing to the full list of Proven Facts. Then, pick out a claim or two and continue to the Sections to see the proof with a detailed presentation of the evidence and explanations.

INTRODUCTION
​​
In 2016-2017, my TD Ameritrade account was relentlessly targeted by schemes to defraud me and steal from my accounts. When I identified discrepancies in the records and inquired in 2017, their representatives denied that any errors existed and refused to honestly answer simple questions. The more I investigated, the more errors I revealed. When I shared these discoveries and demanded explanations, they closed my account and halted all further communication.
​
In 2018, I opened a Schwab account. Immediately, there were problems, and a similar series of denials and account closures ensued. It was as if the scheme that exploited my TD Ameritrade account had followed me to Schwab, and indeed there is considerable evidence supporting the Schwab/TD Ameritrade conspiracy claim, but the immediate objective here is to provide a brief summary of the various fraudulent contrivances and how they operated in concert to perpetrate theft and launder funds while leaving behind only subtle clues in the official records.
​​​
The crucial factual statements are followed by an annotation to the Section and number which identifies where to find the supporting documents and explanation. For example, the annotation at the end of this sentence refers to statement #7 in Section A. [Section A, #7]. (For Section F references, the page numbers are given. - e.g. Section F, pp.1-2)
​​​​​

ERRORS IN THE BROKERAGE STATEMENTS CHALLENGE THEIR AUTHORITY AS THE "OFFICIAL RECORD"
My Schwab brokerage statements are flawed by errors that render them to be inaccurate and incomplete records. Schwab insists that my account statements are flawless, categorically without error. This is simply false; in fact, there are several errors that represent severe vulnerabilities, including the following:
​​
EVERY short sale is reported inaccurately by the “Realized Gain or (Loss)” section of Schwab’s brokerage statements as well as the 1099-B Tax Statement. The positions are reported with “Opened” and “Closed” dates that differ from those reported by the “Transaction Detail.” The FINRA disciplinary action against Barclays Capital published in June 2023 concerned a similar pattern of errors that caused positions to be omitted from the official records. [Section B, #2]​
​
The “Investment Detail” section of the March statement reports six expired options positions as active investments with a non-zero market value (despite their having expired worthless). The “Unrealized losses” associated with these positions were never accounted for as “Realized Losses” [Section B, #1]​
​
Several options positions are reported with “Opened” and “Closed” dates that are AFTER the expiration date for the options contracts. [Section B, #3]
These errors created vulnerabilities that were exploited to eliminate positions from the record, as well as the funds involved with those transactions, strongly supported by the various other contrivances described below involving the Futures Account and discrepancies between the live and historical balances. And, furthermore,
​
Schwab’s systems provided direct confirmation that “Some of your accounts are missing historical data.” [Section B, #2-c.3.]​
​​
​

THE FUTURES ACCOUNT WAS A CENTRAL ELEMENT
TO THE ERRONEOUS ACCOUNTING
Improper Comingling of Futures and Brokerage Accounts
​​
Critical values were miscalculated or otherwise misstated in my Schwab account (e.g., Account Value, Total Cash, and Buying Power). [Section A, #2]. The contorted accounting was caused by comingling the bookkeeping of the Futures Account with the margin account for the brokerage account. [Section A, #3, #5, #6]. It is important to understand that a Futures account is essentially just a margin account designated for Futures transactions and accounting, and brokerages are required to "separately account for all futures customer funds and segregate such funds as belonging to its futures customers." 17 CFR § 1.20. Commingling Futures positions and obligations with the brokerage's margin account holdings is strictly forbidden. In addition to obfuscating key account figures, comingling my Schwab accounts also isolated the Futures account - essentially freeing it up so it could be utilized as the conduit through which stolen funds were laundered.
​
Upon the abrupt closure of the Futures account, the account data was retroactively edited to remove any mention of Futures account from the historical balances and account data, thus destroying the evidence of improper accounting. [Section C, #1, #7, #11].
​​
Theft via Untraceable Debt Originating from the Isolated Futures Account
​
The isolated Futures account secretly extracted cash from the brokerage account. Negative values for Futures Buying Power appear even after the supposed closure of the Futures account. [Section A, #4]. At the end of the month, the live account balances were temporarily manipulated higher to match the values reported by the brokerage statement before reverting to an even lower value. [Section D, #1]. These changes in account value coincided with equal changes to the anomalously stated Futures Buying Power. [Section D, #2]. The account showed “Money Due” equal to the negative Futures Buying Power, yet the total cash for the account remained unchanged, thus lending significant insight into how the contorted Futures accounting operated to conceal theft without visible impact to the brokerage account balances or historical balance data. This mechanism appears to be the means for stealing and laundering funds associated with unreported transactions. As long as there was sufficient money in the account, the brokerage account would be debited without any “Money Due” message occurring. Apparently, they got too greedy and resulted in a deficit that had to be addressed to settle the books for the end of the month.
​
Since historical data was “cleansed” to remove all data pertaining to the Futures account (completely invalid on its face), the evidence of the erroneous accounting and comingling so to was eliminated.
The “Personal Value” balance is supposed to include the total value of all accounts, including brokerage and Futures accounts. Before the Futures account was opened, there were no such issues with “Personal Value.” [Section A, #7]. After the Futures account was opened, however, the “Personal Value” was persistently stated as “$0.00” while Day Change was “N/A.” [Section A, #7, #8]. Also, the Futures Gain/Loss data was continually “grayed out” to zero, concealing the actual activity in the account. [Section A, #3-c]. Since the true Total Account Value and Day Change values were inaccessible while the Futures account was active, the missing options positions (indicated by the Inaccurate Transaction Dates in Brokerage Statements) could have been secretly processed through the Futures account - which is just a margin account.
​
Unreported Transactions and Unaccounted Funds... In my CLOSED Futures Account
​
The July 2018 Futures statement further affirms that the Futures account was utilized to process unreported transactions and unaccounted funds.​​ Schwab closed my Futures account—abruptly and without explanation—at the end of March 2018, supposedly. Indeed, I was unable to access any data from that point forward, and Schwab refused to provide the Futures Statements for the one month that it was officially open. However, over five years later in 2023, Schwab produced Futures account statements which show that the account remained open until at least 2021. [Section A, #1-a; Appendix, 8-27]. Furthermore, the July 2018 Futures Statement reports suspicious, off-setting cash transfers - listed as payments to various exchanges - several months after the supposed closure of the Futures account. [Section A, #1-b]. This directly evidences that my "closed" Futures account was utilized as a pass-through account, presumably to launder stolen funds - as had long been alleged.
​​
Schwab claims no wrongdoing occurred, period. They insist that Futures sweeps and other cash transactions appear accurately accounted for by the brokerage statements, but this is clearly inadequate to explain the unlawful commingling, the litany of resulting errors, and the transactions posted to the account after its supposed closure.
​​​
​
​​​

UNREPORTED TRANSACTIONS AND UNACCOUNTED FUNDS...
IN MY CLOSED FUTURES ACCOUNT
​
The July 2018 Futures statement further affirms that the Futures account was utilized to process unreported transactions and unaccounted funds.​​ Schwab closed my Futures account—abruptly and without explanation—at the end of March 2018, supposedly. Indeed, I was unable to access any data from that point forward, and Schwab refused to provide the Futures Statements for the one month that it was officially open. However, over five years later in 2023, Schwab produced Futures account statements which show that the account remained open until at least 2021. [Section A, #1-a; Appendix, 8-27]. Furthermore, the July 2018 Futures Statement reports suspicious, off-setting cash transfers - listed as payments to various exchanges - several months after the supposed closure of the Futures account. [Section A, #1-b]. This directly evidences that my "closed" Futures account was utilized as a pass-through account, presumably to launder stolen funds - as had long been alleged.
​​
Schwab claims no wrongdoing occurred, period. They insist that Futures sweeps and other cash transactions appear accurately accounted for by the brokerage statements, but this is clearly inadequate to explain the unlawful commingling, the litany of resulting errors, and the transactions posted to the account after its supposed closure.
​​​
​
​​​

COMPARING THE LIVE DATA VS. HISTORICAL BALANCES:
REVEALING THE ELABORATE SCHEME TO MAKE CASH “DISAPPEAR”
​
There are several unreconcilable discrepancies between the “Historical” and ‘Live’ balance data that indicate unaccounted funds and other improprieties that have been concealed from the official records. [see Section C, generally]:
Discrepancies exist in the March 23, 2018 account figures that cannot be explained by the exclusion of the Futures Account from the Historical Data. [Section C - #1]
The Trade Date Balance (stating the cash available at the start of the day) was altered, changed to lower values, thereby making it seem that the cash never existed in the account. [Section C - #3]
The Live Balances display a value for “Funds Available: Cash + Borrowing” that is LESS THAN “Funds Available: Cash Investments”, thereby implying a negative value for ‘Funds Available to Borrow’ – nonsensical and simply impossible. [Section C - #6].
​
The account figures were manipulated to conceal cash value that was ultimately stolen. Schwab insists there are no errors, and that these are merely “perceived discrepancies” attributable to the closure of the Futures Account, at which time the historical balances were adjusted accordingly, and that the only error is in my failure to understand. But, closer inspection of the facts reveals Schwab's defense to be invalid, deliberately deceptive, and simply false:
​​
​​
-
First, the discrepancy in the cash balances nearly match the value of the Futures Account, but not exactly (comparing Historical Balances to the Live data). So, explaining the difference requires consideration of something more than the futures account value, otherwise that difference would be EXACT. [Section C: - #1, #7, #11]
-
Next, in the live data, the discrepancies in the gain/loss figures (Day Change) establish that issues existed before the supposed closure of the Futures Account. [Section C: #2, #7-c, #11.c-2].​​
-
Finally, even if eliminating the Futures Account from the record was a justifiable accounting procedure (despite it serving no useful purpose other than to destroy information), it was not done properly because other values that depended on Futures Account value (such as Margin debt attributable to the sweep transfers) should have also been adjusted accordingly but simply were not. [Section C: #9]
​
The point is... there is no doubt here. My account was defrauded in sophisticated fashion. Schwab may not have been aware at the time, but they continue to deny that any fraud, mistakes, or errors occurred. That is the core of the problem, and it's a terrible injustice.

SCHWAB SECRETLY BLAMED ME FOR THE FRAUD WHILE DENYING THAT ANY ERRORS OR IRREGULARITIES OCCURRED
Schwab claims that no fraud occurred in my account. They insist that my claims are frivolous, baseless, and based on "perceived discrepancies"... they essentially claim that only errors concerning my accounts is my failure to properly interpret the data. Well, as they were making these claims in public court filings, they took action behind the scenes based on a completely different set of fraudulent facts that, apparently, blamed me for the fraud, with devasting effects to my credit worthiness.
​
For more details, go to FRAUD HOTLISTS

Similar Patterns of Error in the TD Ameritrade Account Data
My TD Ameritrade Account was defrauded by similar fraudulent contrivances. The patterns of erroneous recordkeeping and inconsistencies amongst the TD Ameritrade account records reveal further insights into the schemes. First, itthe timekeeping for the cash transaction accounting (Transaction History) was out of sync with the ThinkorSwim platform. These errors persisted for 18 months in 2016-2017, and coincided with various other errors and anomalies in the data, including:
-
Mismatched “Order ID” numbers in the ThinkorSwim data indicate that certain transactions were targeted to be routed through another account as a “man-in-the-middle.” [Section F, pp 1-2]
-
Discrepancies between “live” and “historical” account data reveal erroneous margin accounting concealed cash value. [Section F, pp 9-20]
-
Concealment and laundering of funds through the Futures Account.
-
The Trade Confirmations report some transactions out-of-order with respect to the other records [Section F, pp 13-15] .
-
Unexplained “Courtesy Credit” adjustments that manipulated “yesterday’s” account balances “today” and the erroneous timestamps reported in the Transaction History, ultimately enabling the targeted funds to “disappear." [Section F, pp 19-20] (Similar to altering Trade Date Balance in Schwab Account).
-
Erroneous dating of transactions in the 1099-B Tax statement, virtually identical to the flaws identified in the Schwab records. [Section F, pp 31-33] (see also Section B -Attachment B.28, B.29, B.30)
​